Ameritrade Tops List of Best Online Brokerages
Subscribe to newsletters Subscribe to RSS feeds Post a comment (0 posted) Contact Sean Michael Kerner Articles by Sean Michael Kerner Contact ClickZ Editors View print-friendly version Send article to a colleague
According to a new , "Brokerage Composite Online Rating of Effectiveness (CORE)," Ameritrade is the top online US Brokerage, ranking ahead of competitors including Fidelity, Scottrade, Harrisdirect, Charles Schwab, E-Trade and TD Waterhouse.
The study is based on fourth quarter 2004 data with rankings
based on Jupiter Research's proprietary scoring method that considers
financial variables such as assets under management, number of accounts, and
average daily trade figures, as well as taking various
site traffic variables into consideration.
Jupiter Analyst Asaf Buchner told ClickZ Stats one surprise of the study is that HarrisDirect's frequency results are surprisingly high. "This index measures how frequent their customers visit their site," Buchner said. "Harrisdirect returned a very high measure, meaning that their customers come to the site very often - a few times a month. However, when it comes to actually executing trades they didn't score very high."
Ameritrade has a higher degree of "hyper-usage" (a high percentage
of active traders) than its competitors. A high degree of customer minutes per month, or "customer-intensity," as well as the firm's overall results contributed to Ameritrade's top billing.
At the end of June, Ameritrade announced it will acquire the US operations of online brokerage TD Waterhouse, a move that could jeopardize Ameritrade's top status in the next report. The report says TD Waterhouse has a higher number of casual traders than Ameritrade.
The combined Ameritrade/TD Waterhouse online brokerage is still expected to
trail behind Fidelity in terms of overall customer accounts.
Anointing Ameritrade as the top US online brokerage is in start contrast to a September, 2004, report from J.D. Power & Associates which ranked Ameritrade ninth out of 11 online brokerages. That online brokerage ranking was measured in terms of investor satisfaction. The reigning online brokerage firm according to J.D. Power is Scottrade, a position that firm has held for five consecutive years.
Jupiter's Buchner explains the CORE methodology doesn't include a satisfaction measure. "Rather we look at size [number of accounts, assets under management, number of unique visitors] and activity ]trade, minutes on the site, number of
visits]," Buchner said. "Although in the long run, a firm cannot stay on the
top of the index unless it maintains at least a certain level of satisfaction."
The Jupiter study also looks at what matters most to different
types of traders. Price was by far the leading response. Over half (54 percent) of more frequent traders and 42 percent of occasional traders (less that five trades per year) rank price as the issue that matters most.
Usability is second among regular traders at 34 percent, while only
scoring 27 percent among occasional traders. Speed-of-execution is third for
regular traders at 34 percent. Occasional traders rank quality of service
at 33 percent.
